Responsive Menu
Add more content here...

2026 FELA Decision: Court Rejects Norfolk Southern’s Argument That Federal Safety Law Blocked a One-Person RCO Negligence Claim

A railroad’s compliance with federal safety regulations does not necessarily mean it provided a reasonably safe workplace. That distinction was central to a March 16, 2026, decision involving Norfolk Southern Railway Company and a Remote Control Operator (RCO) who suffered serious injuries while working alone in an Indiana railyard.

In Norfolk Southern Railway Company v. Scott Sporner, the Indiana Court of Appeals rejected the railroad’s argument that federal safety law prevented an injured worker from pursuing a Federal Employers’ Liability Act (FELA) negligence claim based on the use of a one-person RCO crew. The court concluded that federal railroad safety regulations do not automatically eliminate a railroad’s obligation to exercise reasonable care under FELA. On August 27, 2026, the Indiana Supreme Court declined to review the case, leaving the appellate ruling in place.

Although McEldrew Purtell did not represent the worker or participate in this litigation, the ruling raises important questions about railroad staffing, operating practices, and workplace safety.

For conductors, engineers, remote control operators, and other railroad employees, the decision reinforces an important point: complying with federal regulations does not necessarily resolve whether a railroad acted negligently.

What Happened in the Norfolk Southern Railyard?

On January 4, 2021, Scott Sporner was working as an RCO at Norfolk Southern’s Elkhart, Indiana, railyard. He was operating as a one-person crew, controlling a train with a handheld remote control device.

According to the Indiana Court of Appeals’ decision, a yardmaster instructed Sporner to move his train east. However, the yardmaster did not realize another Norfolk Southern train was stationary farther east on the same track.

Sporner followed the instruction and began moving his train. At the time, he was positioned aboard the westernmost locomotive, away from the direction of travel. He was not positioned to maintain a lookout ahead of the movement. His train collided with the stationary train, seriously injuring him.

The court’s opinion describes injuries involving his head, shoulder, and hip, along with evidence of persistent neurological symptoms, balance problems, and tinnitus. Sporner subsequently pursued a FELA negligence claim against Norfolk Southern.

A jury found Norfolk Southern 60% responsible for the incident and Sporner 40% responsible. The jury assessed total damages of $8.2 million. After the comparative-fault reduction, the trial court entered a judgment of $4.92 million against Norfolk Southern. The Indiana Court of Appeals affirmed the judgment in March 2026.

This verdict resulted from litigation handled by attorneys unaffiliated with McEldrew Purtell. It is discussed here solely to explain the court’s decision and its potential significance for railroad workers. Case outcomes depend on the specific facts and evidence involved.

Norfolk Southern Argued Federal Law Permitted One-Person RCO Crews

One of Norfolk Southern’s central arguments concerned the relationship between FELA and the Federal Railroad Safety Act (FRSA). The railroad argued that because federal regulations permitted one-person remote-control operations, it could not be found negligent under FELA merely for assigning one employee to operate the equipment.

Essentially, Norfolk Southern maintained that compliance with federal crew-size regulations prevented the jury from considering whether additional crew members were necessary for safe operations. The railroad asked the courts to remove that theory of negligence from the case. The Indiana Court of Appeals rejected that argument.

The Court Ruled That Federal Safety Regulations Do Not Automatically Eliminate FELA Claims

The appellate court examined how the FRSA and FELA operate together. The FRSA establishes a national framework for regulating railroad safety. FELA, by contrast, allows qualifying railroad employees to pursue compensation when railroad negligence contributes to their injuries.

Norfolk Southern argued that the regulatory framework established under the FRSA should control the crew-size issue. The court disagreed. Relying on federal statutory interpretation principles and other decisions addressing the relationship between the two laws, the court concluded that the FRSA does not automatically prevent a worker from pursuing a negligence claim under FELA.

In particular, the court determined that the railroad’s compliance with federal law did not necessarily resolve the question of whether using a one-person RCO crew was negligent under the circumstances. The distinction is significant.

A federal regulation may permit a particular railroad operating practice without establishing that the practice is reasonably safe in every situation.

The court did not declare one-person RCO operations unlawful. Instead, it held that Norfolk Southern was not entitled to judgment as a matter of law simply because federal regulations permitted that staffing arrangement. The negligence claim could be considered based on the actual circumstances surrounding the incident.

Indiana Supreme Court Declines to Review the Decision

The case saw another important development on August 27, 2026, when the Indiana Supreme Court denied Norfolk Southern’s petition to transfer the appeal.

The decision leaves the Indiana Court of Appeals’ March 16, 2026 ruling in place, including its conclusion that federal railroad safety regulations do not automatically prevent an injured railroad worker from pursuing a FELA negligence claim involving one-person RCO operations.

The Indiana Supreme Court’s official transfer disposition report confirms that all justices concurred in denying transfer.

The denial does not mean the Indiana Supreme Court independently endorsed the appellate court’s reasoning or issued a new ruling on the merits. Rather, the published Court of Appeals decision remains in place.

What Do Federal Regulations Say About One-Person RCO Crews?

The Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) regulates numerous aspects of railroad operations, including crew-size requirements. Under 49 C.F.R. § 218.121, federal minimum crew-size requirements do not apply to train operations controlled by remote control operators.

The regulation also describes federal crew-size requirements as minimum standards and recognizes that railroads may establish more stringent operating requirements. That distinction is important.

A regulatory exemption does not necessarily answer whether a particular assignment, operating practice, or staffing decision was reasonably safe under the conditions involved.

In Sporner, the court allowed the worker’s FELA theory to proceed despite Norfolk Southern’s argument that federal regulations permitted a single-employee RCO crew. This does not mean railroads must use two-person RCO crews in every situation.

It means that federal regulatory compliance does not automatically defeat a FELA negligence claim involving crew size.

Why the Decision Matters for Railroad Workers

The ruling is particularly relevant to railroad employees involved in remote-control operations, switching movements, and other yard activities where staffing and visibility can affect workplace safety.

Railroads frequently rely on federal operating regulations and internal rules when defending their practices after an accident. Those requirements matter. However, a FELA negligence analysis may involve additional questions about whether the railroad acted reasonably under the circumstances.

For example:

  • Did the staffing arrangement allow employees to perform the movement safely?
  • Was the employee positioned where they could adequately observe the movement?
  • Did the yardmaster or supervisor know whether the track ahead was occupied?
  • Were appropriate communications and job briefings conducted?
  • Did railroad supervisors recognize hazards associated with the assignment?
  • Were additional personnel or other safety precautions reasonably necessary?
  • Did the railroad’s own operating rules require additional precautions?

The answers depend on the specific facts of each incident.

For employees injured during yard, switching, and coupling operations, these issues may become important when determining whether railroad negligence contributed to an injury.

A Railroad’s Safety Responsibilities Extend Beyond Minimum Compliance

The decision also highlights a broader issue in railroad injury litigation. Railroads must comply with applicable federal safety requirements. But compliance with a particular rule does not necessarily establish that every aspect of an operation was reasonably safe. Under FELA, injured employees generally must establish that railroad negligence played some part in causing their injuries.

Evidence may involve staffing decisions, supervision, training, communication, operating procedures, equipment conditions, or known workplace hazards. The railroad’s compliance with applicable regulations can be relevant to that analysis, but it is not necessarily conclusive.

Understanding how FELA works is important because FELA is a negligence-based federal law, not a traditional workers’ compensation system.

The Court Also Upheld Evidence Supporting Future Lost Wages

Norfolk Southern challenged another aspect of the jury’s verdict: the evidence supporting Sporner’s future lost earnings. The railroad argued that the worker’s claim of being unable to return to competitive employment lacked sufficient evidentiary support. The appellate court disagreed.

The record included testimony from medical professionals, a vocational rehabilitation expert, and an economist concerning Sporner’s injuries, employment limitations, and projected future wage loss. The court concluded that the evidence was sufficient to support the jury’s consideration of future lost earnings. This portion of the decision reinforces the importance of documenting the long-term consequences of serious railroad injuries.

Depending on the circumstances, a FELA claim may involve more than immediate medical expenses or time missed from work. A worker’s permanent restrictions, lost earning capacity, ongoing medical needs, pain, and other consequences may be relevant to damages. These issues are especially significant when a railroad employee suffers a serious injury that affects their ability to return to their previous occupation.

Does This Ruling Mean One-Person RCO Crews Are Unsafe?

Not necessarily. The Indiana Court of Appeals did not establish a nationwide prohibition on one-person RCO operations. Nor did it determine that assigning a single employee to remote-control operations automatically constitutes negligence. Instead, the ruling addresses whether federal railroad safety law bars an injured worker from presenting a FELA negligence claim based on crew size. The court held that it does not.

This is an important distinction because railroad injury claims depend on the specific circumstances surrounding an accident. An operation may satisfy federal regulatory requirements while still raising questions about staffing, visibility, supervision, or other precautions that may have been reasonably necessary. Whether those circumstances establish negligence requires evidence and legal analysis.

The Sporner decision is a published Indiana appellate ruling, not a U.S. Supreme Court decision establishing a universally binding rule for every FELA case nationwide. Its reasoning may nevertheless be relevant to similar disputes.

What Should Railroad Workers Do After an RCO or Yard Injury?

When a serious injury occurs during remote-control operations or yard movements, the facts surrounding the assignment can be critical. Employees should seek appropriate medical treatment, report the incident accurately, and preserve any available information about the conditions that led to the injury.

Relevant evidence may include job briefings, crew assignments, radio communications, operating instructions, witness information, movement records, equipment data, and documentation of previous safety concerns.

Workers should also be careful not to assume that a railroad’s compliance with federal regulations means they have no potential FELA claim. The circumstances may warrant a closer examination of whether the railroad exercised reasonable care.

Following the appropriate steps after a railroad workplace injury can help protect important evidence and ensure workers better understand their options.

Injured During Remote-Control, Switching, or Yard Operations?

The 2026 Sporner decision reinforces an important principle: federal regulatory compliance does not necessarily eliminate a railroad’s responsibility to provide a reasonably safe workplace.

McEldrew Purtell represents injured railroad workers and their families in FELA matters involving unsafe operating practices, inadequate staffing, equipment failures, serious workplace injuries, and allegations of railroad negligence.

If you were seriously injured while working as an RCO or during switching or yard operations, our railroad injury attorneys can review the circumstances of your accident, explain your rights under FELA, and assess whether railroad negligence may have contributed to your injuries.

Contact McEldrew Purtell for a free, confidential consultation.

Legal Insight: Defining the Ownership of Tracks in Philadelphia – Where Should I Look?

This article was created by the Philadelphia Trial Lawyers Association for The Verdict newsletter in conjunction with Cormick McLaughlin of McEldrew Purtell and is intended to provide legal insight into the ownership of railroad tracks in the Philadelphia area.

Finding out who owns the property where an injury occurred is an essential first step for an attorney. Ownership can inform who is responsible for maintaining that property and who can be held liable if they are negligent. In Philadelphia and its surrounding suburbs, the Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority (SEPTA) operates an extensive transportation network including regional rail services, trolley service, and subway service.

Despite SEPTA overseeing the scheduling and maintenance of the trains and trolleys themselves, the ownership of the tracks, surrounding areas, and the maintenance thereof can be a more complicated question. The purpose of this article is to examine who owns Philadelphia’s train and trolley tracks, who is responsible for the maintenance of those tracks and the surrounding areas, and to provide resources that can help you identify those parties.

SEPTA and Its Different Types of Tracks

To get an understanding of who is responsible for the maintenance and care of a section of track and its surrounding area, the first thing we must do is figure out what type of track or surrounding infrastructure our client’s case is concerned with. When it comes to SEPTA operating vehicles on a track in Philadelphia and its surrounding suburbs, there are three categories which for the purposes of this article we will refer to as Trolley Track, Subway Track, and Regional Rail Track.

Trolley Track

Trolley Track is used for streetcar service throughout the city. SEPTA has and continues to provide service on these fixed tracks that operate on the surface of city streets along with motor vehicle, bicycle, and pedestrian traffic. In Philadelphia, Trolley Track presents an interesting problem as there are significant portions where service has been completely abandoned, yet the track itself remains.

In a 1991 case that came to the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania for appellate review after arbitration, the Court gave a thorough explanation of who is responsible for the maintenance of Trolley Track and how that came to be. See Yackobovitz v. SEPTA, 139 Pa. Commw. 157, 590 A.2d 40 (1991).

This case began when the Plaintiff fell into a pothole located within eighteen inches of a SEPTA trolley rail on Allegheny Avenue which also happens to be “adopted” as a state highway. Id. at 162. As a result, plaintiff filed suit against both PennDot and SEPTA. PennDot and SEPTA joined the city of Philadelphia as an additional Defendant.

In Yackobovitz the parties stipulated that “the trolley track facilities on Allegheny Avenue where Marie Yackobovitz fell are subject to an Agreement and Lease entered into between SEPTA and the City on September 26, 1968 (Lease), and that this agreement and another agreement (Leaseback) the parties signed at the same time address the issue of “Leased Property” maintenance.” Id. at 162-63. The parties further stipulated that “the controlling legal issue was the determination of who was responsible for the maintenance of the trolley track area, including the trolley rails, the roadbed between the rails, and the roadbed within eighteen inches of the outermost rails on the day Marie Yackobovitz complained of her fall.” Id. at 163.

On review, the Yackobovitz Court stated “[I]t has been consistently held that unless altered by contract or ordinance, the entity operating a street railway is obligated to maintain and repair those portions of the streets on which its street railway tracks are located.” Id. at 164; see also Culver v. Lehigh Valley Transport Co., 322 Pa. 503, 507, 186 A.2d 70, 72 (1936). Historically a street railway company is required to maintain the “space between the rails and for eighteen inches on each side of them, in a safe and passable condition and repair as a duty or obligation incident to its operation of the . . . railway line . . .” Id. quoting Township of Horsham v. Public Service Commission, 97 Pa. Superior Ct. 366 (1929). Though this common law interpretation is of some use to those trying to figure out who is responsible for maintenance, in this case the issue became muddled through the contracting done between SEPTA and the City. Id. at 166-168. Ultimately, the court found through interpretation of the agreements between the City and SEPTA, that SEPTA was responsible for the maintenance of the street railway roadbed. Id. at 169.

This case serves to highlight a fact well known to Plaintiff’s attorneys. Who is responsible for maintenance may appear like a straightforward issue, but it is important not to let yourself be blinded by what is in front of you and ask the right questions during the investigation and discovery of a case to protect your client’s interests.

Subway Track

When we are thinking about Subway Track in Philadelphia, we may have to rethink the name. It is well known that Philadelphia has two major subway lines, the Broad Street Line and the Market-Frankford Line, recently redubbed “B” and “L” respectively. The difficulty with deeming them “subways” comes from the significant portions of the Market-Frankford or “L” which are elevated.

Without further digression we can look once again to the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania for a thorough examination of the ownership and maintenance responsibilities near subway track in Philadelphia. In Smith v. SEPTA, 707 A.2d 604 (Pa. Commw. Ct. 1998), both the City and SEPTA were appealing the trial court’s denial of their respective post-trial motions. The jury found both SEPTA and the City liable for injuries suffered on the sidewalk outside of a Broad Street Line Station, importantly SEPTA had previously done maintenance work on this sidewalk. In its opinion the court examined the bounds of SEPTA’s maintenance responsibility and provides other facts that can help us understand where responsibility for maintenance around SEPTA Subway Track begins and ends.

The Court once again referred to the leasing agreement between the City and SEPTA mentioned in Yackobovitz, supra. The trial court provided the jury with limited portions of the lease agreement between the City and SEPTA, including section 1.12 (requiring SEPTA to maintain the Leased Properties in good and safe operating condition), section 2.01(requiring the City to build Broad Street subway extensions), and section 2.04 (requiring SEPTA to maintain the extensions in first-class physical condition, normal wear and tear excepted.) Smith v. SEPTA at 607. The Smith Court found that the jury was entitled to interpret the lease between SEPTA and the City as assigning SEPTA the responsibility to maintain the sidewalk outside of the Broad Street Line Station. Leading up to this finding the Court mentions other portions of the lease which required the parties to make an inventory of “paid areas for which the operator of the transit system is responsible and free areas for which the City is responsible.” Id. at 608.

This interpretation of the agreements between SEPTA and the City provides Plaintiff’s attorneys with important information on the expansive maintenance responsibilities which SEPTA may have for maintaining the areas around Subway Track. SEPTA’s responsibility can, under the right circumstances, go beyond the stairways leading to their subway stops and the platforms on which people wait for their ride and include the sidewalks leading up to those stairwells or underground entrances. In other words, even if it seems like property that would fall under the City’s maintenance responsibilities, it may be worth the time to include SEPTA if they have a nearby facility.

Regional Rail Track

SEPTA’s Regional Rail is the most expansive of the operations being discussed in this article. The Regional Rail Track covers ground in Philadelphia County, Montgomery County, Delaware County, Bucks County, New Jersey, and Delaware. With the scale of operation, it should be no surprise that who owns the track and is responsible for the maintenance surrounding it is a more complicated question than the prior two sections of this article.

After SEPTA’s establishment they gradually acquired direct ownership of many rail assets from private railroad companies such as The Pennsylvania Railroad and The Reading Railroad. We will not focus on the portions of track that are under SEPTA’s direct ownership as they are the majority. Instead, it is important to know that there are locations on SEPTA’s lines where they are using infrastructure from other private entities such as AMTRAK. In situations where AMTRAK owns the track, such as on SEPTA’s Trenton Line, Paoli/Thorndale Line, and Wilmington/Newark Line, SEPTA leases the track rights or operates through cooperative agreements.

With its large scale and the intricacies of the various agreements SEPTA’s Regional Rail maintains with other rail services providers and governments it is important that Plaintiff’s attorneys make sound discovery requests to examine who is responsible for ownership and maintenance at any given portion of track, station, or parking lot associated with SEPTA’s Regional Rail. Unfortunately, there is no one size fits all when it comes to injuries occurring at or near SEPTA’s Regional Rail. You will need to discover the agreements and dig in to find out who is responsible for the conditions that caused injury to your client.

Where to Look?

The maps SEPTA provides on its website are a valuable resource when a client first calls to inform you that they have been injured at or near a SEPTA station. Once you can establish a location you can rule out some of the intricacies noted above. If the injury occurred near, at, or on Subway or Trolley Tracks you know that the majority of the work will be investigating the current agreements between SEPTA and the municipality. Most likely that municipality will be the City of Philadelphia.

When it comes to regional rail, as noted above, things may get more complex. This is when you may have to dig into federal railroad legislation, the Pennsylvania Public Utility Code, and any shared use agreements governed by the Surface Transportation Board. It may also be necessary to discover documents such as SEPTA’s annual reports along with any contracts or lease agreements which are relevant to the issues in your case.

Armed with the fact that ownership and maintenance of the various tracks that provide transportation throughout the City of Philadelphia and its surrounding suburbs isn’t always a straightforward question, you can confidently ask the right questions and look in the right places during discovery. Doing this will ensure that your client’s rights are protected, and responsible parties are held accountable.

Jim McEldrew Discussing Amtrak Derailment on Fox News

Gretchen Carlson of Fox News interviewed Jim McEldrew this afternoon on her television show. Jim has been representing injured individuals in railroad litigation for more than thirty years and formerly served as the President of the Academy of Rail Labor Attorneys. They discussed the implications of the foreign object and the potential for the railroad engineer to be confused as to his geographical position on the tracks.

Earlier today, Jim was also interviewed on Knowledge@Wharton, a daily call-in business interview program hosted by Dan Loney on SiriusXM channel 111.  On the air with Dr. Allan Zarembski, a Research Professor and Director of Railroad Engineering and Safety Program at the University of Delaware, Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, they discussed the Amtrak derailment, Congressional funding and railroad safety.

Jim McEldrew on Positive Train Control in the Philadelphia Inquirer

McEldrew Purtell Partner and Railroad Attorney James J. McEldrew, III had his commentary on Positive Train Control published on the Philadelphia Inquirer website today.  The article discusses the need for the automated system mandated by Congress in 2008 to be implemented by Amtrak and other railroads to prevent accidents like the one last night. It’s titled “U.S. railroad’s must adopt ‘train control’ now.”